Discuss the narrative techniques adopted by Emily Bronte in Wuthering Heights. Explain how the complex narrative reflects multiple voices
Get the full solved assignment PDF of MEG-03 of 2024-25 session now by clicking on above button.
In Wuthering Heights, Emily Brontë employs a complex narrative structure that incorporates multiple voices and perspectives, creating a layered and multifaceted storytelling technique. The novel’s narrative is non-linear, framed by two main narrators—Lockwood and Nelly Dean—whose perspectives guide the reader through the tangled histories of the characters. This multiplicity of voices allows Brontë to convey different interpretations of events, offering a deeper exploration of the characters’ inner worlds and the themes of the novel, such as love, revenge, and the supernatural.
1. Framed Narrative
The novel uses a framed narrative structure, where the story is told within another story. The primary narrator, Lockwood, is an outsider who visits Wuthering Heights and becomes intrigued by the inhabitants and their dark, mysterious past. His narration frames the main events of the novel, which are recounted to him by Nelly Dean, a servant with intimate knowledge of both the Earnshaw and Linton families.
This framing technique creates a sense of distance between the reader and the events, emphasizing the novel’s mysterious, almost mythic atmosphere. The reader is never given a direct, omniscient view of the story; instead, the narrative unfolds through layers of interpretation, as Lockwood and Nelly provide their own versions of events. This adds to the novel’s ambiguity, as the truth is filtered through these subjective perspectives.
2. Multiple Perspectives
The use of multiple narrators adds complexity to the narrative, as each narrator brings their own biases, limitations, and interpretations. Lockwood is an outsider, unfamiliar with the intricacies of the relationships at Wuthering Heights, and his early judgments are often inaccurate. His narration is colored by his detachment from the emotional intensity of the characters and their conflicts. For example, when he first meets Heathcliff, he misjudges him as merely a gruff, unsocial figure, unaware of the deep emotional turmoil that drives him.
In contrast, Nelly Dean, as a lifelong servant of both the Earnshaw and Linton families, provides a more detailed and insider view of the characters and events. However, Nelly is not a neutral observer; her narrative is shaped by her personal opinions, moral judgments, and social position. She often presents herself as a voice of reason and moderation, but her biases—such as her disapproval of Catherine Earnshaw’s passionate nature or her view of Heathcliff as inherently malevolent—affect the way she recounts events.
By presenting the story through these different lenses, Brontë encourages the reader to question the reliability of each narrator and to consider the story from multiple angles, reflecting the complexity of human relationships and motivations.
3. Unreliable Narrators
Both Lockwood and Nelly can be considered unreliable narrators to some extent. Lockwood’s unreliability stems from his ignorance of the local culture and the depth of the relationships he observes. His initial impressions are often superficial, and his misunderstanding of the intense emotional and psychological bonds between the characters adds a layer of detachment.
Nelly, though more knowledgeable, has her own biases and personal involvement in the events she describes. As a servant, her position allows her access to the inner workings of the household, but it also means that she interprets events from a class-conscious perspective. She often downplays her role in key events and manipulates the narrative to present herself in a favorable light. Her version of the story may omit or obscure certain details, leaving the reader to wonder about the full truth behind the events she recounts.
This unreliability reflects the novel’s themes of ambiguity, secrecy, and the unknowability of human motivations, forcing the reader to engage more actively with the text and piece together the story from the various, often conflicting, accounts.
4. Non-Linear Structure
The narrative in Wuthering Heights is also non-linear, with frequent flashbacks and shifts in time. Much of the novel is set in the past, as Nelly recounts the history of the Earnshaw and Linton families to Lockwood. The use of flashbacks creates a sense of fragmentation, as the reader is taken back and forth between different time periods, piecing together the events that have shaped the present situation at Wuthering Heights.
This fragmented narrative mirrors the chaotic and tumultuous nature of the characters’ lives and relationships. The non-linear structure also allows Brontë to gradually reveal key details, heightening the sense of mystery and suspense. Events are often foreshadowed or hinted at before being fully explained, creating a layered and suspenseful reading experience.
5. Embedded Narratives and Multiple Voices
In addition to the two main narrators, Brontë incorporates embedded narratives—stories within stories—that give voice to other characters. For instance, Isabella Linton’s letter to Nelly provides a firsthand account of her experiences with Heathcliff after their marriage, offering a perspective that neither Nelly nor Lockwood can provide. These embedded narratives contribute to the novel’s richness, allowing secondary characters to express their own emotions and viewpoints, further complicating the reader’s understanding of the events.
The inclusion of these multiple voices creates a polyphonic narrative, where no single perspective dominates. Instead, Brontë presents a chorus of voices, each contributing to the overall story while also reflecting the complexity of individual experiences.
Conclusion
Emily Brontë’s narrative techniques in Wuthering Heights—including the framed narrative, multiple and unreliable narrators, non-linear structure, and embedded stories—reflect the novel’s thematic complexity. By presenting the story through various perspectives, Brontë allows for a rich and multifaceted exploration of love, revenge, class, and the supernatural. The novel’s intricate narrative structure mirrors the emotional and psychological depths of its characters, creating a haunting and immersive reading experience that engages the reader in actively interpreting and understanding the events.