Would you agree that Milton reflects on blindness in Sonnets 19 & 23? Give a reasoned answer

Get the full solved assignment PDF of MEG-01 of 2024-25 session now by clicking on above button.

Yes, Milton does reflect on his blindness in Sonnets 19 (“When I consider how my light is spent”) and Sonnets 23 (“Methought I saw my late espoused saint”). Both sonnets delve into personal and emotional aspects of his life, and while they don’t explicitly mention blindness in every line, they are influenced by Milton’s personal experience of losing his sight. Let’s explore how these two sonnets reflect on blindness and how Milton uses his blindness as a thematic and emotional foundation.

Sonnet 19: “When I Consider How My Light Is Spent”

This sonnet directly addresses Milton’s blindness and his anxiety about how he can serve God despite his disability. The phrase “light is spent” is a metaphor for Milton’s loss of sight. He reflects on the frustration of being blind, especially given his ambition and desire to continue his poetic and intellectual work. Milton grapples with the idea of divine justice, wondering how he can fulfill God’s purpose if his blindness prevents him from being productive.

Reflection on Blindness: The sonnet is infused with Milton’s concerns about the limitations his blindness imposes on his ability to write and serve God. He says, “That one Talent which is death to hide / Lodged with me useless,” expressing the fear that his talents will go to waste because of his disability. This is a clear reflection of his personal struggle with the implications of his blindness on his work and purpose.
Resolution: The sonnet moves toward a theological resolution. In the famous line, “They also serve who only stand and wait,” Milton comes to terms with his condition, suggesting that passive submission to God’s will is also a form of service. Here, his blindness is not seen as a punishment or hindrance but as part of God’s divine plan, implying that one’s value isn’t limited to physical abilities or productivity.

Sonnet 23: “Methought I Saw My Late Espoused Saint”

In this sonnet, Milton reflects on a dream where he sees his deceased wife, but the theme of blindness is present in a more subtle way. While the focus of the poem is on Milton’s grief and longing for his lost wife, it also implicitly reflects his blindness, as his vision of her occurs in a dream, a realm where he can “see” again.

Reflection on Blindness: In the dream, Milton sees his wife clearly, and the joy of this sight contrasts with his waking blindness. He refers to her “veilèd” appearance, but this could symbolize both the veil between life and death and his inability to see in reality. His experience of sight in the dream may represent a fleeting escape from his blindness, but it is only temporary. When he wakes up, he is “unseen” and blind once more. Thus, the poem indirectly reflects his blindness by highlighting how dreams provide a space where he can “see” what is lost to him in reality.
Spiritual Vision: Beyond the physical blindness, the sonnet touches upon the idea of spiritual sight. Milton’s vision of his wife is more than just a dream—it’s a manifestation of spiritual connection and love that transcends the physical world. His blindness, therefore, becomes secondary to his ability to perceive her in this otherworldly, spiritual form.

Comparing the Two Sonnets:

Both sonnets deal with the theme of blindness but in different ways:

Sonnet 19 confronts blindness directly, focusing on Milton’s anxiety about how it affects his ability to serve God. The theme of blindness here is literal, and Milton reflects on the limitations and frustrations of losing his sight. His resolution is one of acceptance, emphasizing patience and passive service to God.
Sonnet 23, on the other hand, deals with blindness more indirectly. Here, the reflection on blindness comes through the dream where Milton is temporarily relieved from the physical limitations of his blindness. The sonnet touches upon spiritual vision, where the physical limitations of blindness are surpassed by the inner, emotional, and spiritual connection with his deceased wife.

Conclusion:

Both sonnets reflect on Milton’s blindness, though in different ways. Sonnet 19 is a direct meditation on his disability and the struggle to reconcile his personal limitations with his religious faith and sense of purpose. Sonnet 23 subtly integrates the theme of blindness by showing how Milton, even in his blindness, can still “see” through dreams and spiritual vision. Together, these sonnets reveal Milton’s complex relationship with his blindness, where he balances frustration with faith, despair with hope, and physical limitations with spiritual insight.